Acceptability
of Potential Mosquito Control Activities
Introduction:
In this section, we will discuss various methods to control Aedes
aegypti mosquitos, which
can transmit diseases such as dengue, Zika, and chikungunya.
These mosquito control methods are used at different stages in
the mosquito life cycle, so we will begin by explaining the
mosquito life cycle:
Interviewer:
Explain here the Aedes aegypti
mosquito life cycle, using the visual aid card or the video of
the Aedes aegypti mosquito life cycle. If using the visual aid
card, read the script below.
It
is a dark-colored mosquito, with white bands on its legs and
body. It likes to be close to people, inside and outside houses.
Aedes
aegypti
mosquitos bite mainly during daytime, although they will bite at
night under artificial lighting.
Only
female mosquitos bite, they need to obtain blood to produce
their eggs. Male
mosquitoes don’t bite.
Female
mosquitoes lay their eggs on the walls of any water-holding
container, inside or outside homes.
Eggs
can survive up to 8 months stuck to the walls of containers
where they are laid.
When
eggs come in contact with in water, larvae hatch.
Larvae
live in water where they feed and become pupae in as little as 5
days and stay near the surface where they breathe.
After
2 to 3 days, pupae become adult flying mosquitoes.
It
can take just 7 to 10 days for an egg to become an adult
mosquito.
Now
we will talk about some methods used to control mosquitos. I will
briefly explain each method. All of these methods have been used
previously in the United States, Puerto Rico, or in other
countries. I would like to know if you think these actions could
be useful in your community. There are no right or wrong answers,
I would just like to know your opinion.
PID:
I
1_0.
Have you ever heard of indoor residual spraying (IRS)?
Interviewer: Show
the visual aid for IRS.
Interviewer
read the following:
In
this type of spraying, a licensed professional worker sprays the
walls and other surfaces inside a house with a long-lasting
insecticide, meaning that the insecticide continues working for
several months.
This
way, the mosquitoes that rest on the sprayed surfaces, die.
It
might have a slight odor for several hours after applying it,
but it does not cause harm to people when it is done correctly.
It
requires the permission and availability of a resident to enter
the house to spray.
To
be effective in reducing number of mosquitoes, it needs to be
applied to the majority of houses in an area.
The
spraying should be reapplied every 1 to 3 months to keep
mosquito populations low.
Over
time, with repeated use, mosquitoes can become resistant to
insecticides. Resistance means that the mosquitoes get used to
the insecticide and do not die when they rest on sprayed
surfaces.
IRS
has been used in many countries, including PR and USA.
Yes |
No | Doesn’t
know | No
response
PID:
I1_1. Would
you support the use of indoor
residual spraying?
Interviewer:
Read the responses.
Support
Neutral
Oppose
No response
|
|
|
|
I1_2.
What
are the reasons you oppose?
Interviewer:
Do
not suggest responses. Choose all reasons mentioned below.
Use “other” for reasons not listed.
Environmental impact
Wild animal health
Human health
Pet health
Don’t think it
is/would be effective in this community
Not a community
priority/arboviruses are not a concern here
Strong smell
Other:
_____________________________
|
|
I2_0. Have you ever heard of AGO traps for mosquitoes?
Interviewer: Show
the visual aid for AGO traps.
Interviewer
read the following:
AGOs
have two components: a 5-galon black plastic container with
water and hay, and a capture chamber that contains sticky paper
and a metal screen.
The
water and hay, and the dark color of the trap, attract female
mosquitoes that look for containers to lay their eggs.
Once
the female mosquito is inside the capture chamber of the trap,
the screen prevents it reaching the water.
When
the mosquito rests on the walls of the capture chamber, it gets
stuck to the sticky paper.
No
professionally trained staff are needed to install the trap.
Traps
require maintenance every 2 months to maintain efficacy and
avoid becoming mosquito breeding sites.
To
reduce the number of mosquitoes, AGOs must be used in the
majority of houses in a community.
AGOs
have been used in several places in Puerto Rico, including
Caguas and Salinas, and have reduced the number of mosquitoes.
Yes |
No | Doesn’t
know | No
response
I2_1.
Would you support the use of AGO
traps for mosquitoes?
Interviewer:
Read the responses.
Support
Neutral
Oppose
No response
|
|
|
|
I2_2.
What are the reasons you oppose?
Interviewer:
Do
not suggest responses. Choose all reasons mentioned below.
Use “other” for reasons not listed.
Environmental impact
Wild animal health
Human health
Pet health
Don’t think it
is/would be effective in this community
Not a community
priority/arboviruses are not a concern here
If the traps are not maintained
they can become mosquito
breeding sites
Other:
_____________________________
|
|
Sterile Insect Technique
Interviewer
read the following:
Sterile
Insect Technique is a method to control insects and has been
used for many different insect species.
The
principle of the sterile insect technique involves releasing
many sterile male insects to compete with wild fertile male
insects.
When
a female mates with an introduced sterile male, there are no
offspring and the population of the insects will decrease.
In
mosquitoes, there are different ways of making the males
sterile. Examples include: genetic modification and introduction
of a bacteria. Both of these are created in a lab.
Large
numbers (many thousands) of sterile mosquitoes need to be
released periodically in order to keep the number of sterile
males stable within a population.
This
technique can be used in many different insects and has been
used primarily in agriculture.
Each
use of sterile insect technique is species-specific and does not
pose a risk to humans or other animals or insects.
Now
we will discuss two ways of using sterile insect technique in
mosquitoes.
I3_0. Have you ever heard of male
genetically modified (GM) mosquitoes?
Interviewer: Show
the visual aid for male GM mosquitoes.
Interviewer
read the following:
In
this method, male genetically modified mosquitoes are released.
Female mosquitoes are not released.
Genetically
modified mosquitoes are mosquitoes that have had part of their
genetic information changed in a
laboratory.
These
male mosquitoes mate with wild females and pass to their
offspring a gene that prevents larvae and pupae from developing
normally. In this way, larvae and pupae die before they become
adult mosquitoes.
These
mosquitoes need to be released several times per week for a
prolonged period to keep the mosquito populations low.
Mosquito
population will eventually increase again when the releases of
genetically modified mosquitoes stop.
The
use of genetically modified mosquitoes is safe for people,
animals, and the environment.
GM
male mosquitoes have been used in Brasil, Panama, and Cayman
Islands.
At
present, they have not been evaluated in the US, but permissions
have been granted for evaluations to take place in a number of
states in the US.
Yes |
No | Doesn’t
know | No
response
I3_1. Would you support the use of male genetically modified
mosquitoes?
Interviewer:
Read the responses.
Support
Neutral
Oppose
No
response
|
|
|
|
I3_2.
What are the reasons you oppose?
Interviewer:
Do
not suggest responses. Choose all reasons mentioned below.
Use “other” for reasons not listed.
Environmental impact
Wild animal health
Human health
Pet health
Don’t think it
is/would be effective in this community
Not a community
priority/arboviruses are not a concern here
Concerned about
safety of use of GM mosquitoes
GM mosquitoes could
transmit their genes to other mosquitoes,
people, or animals
Other:
_____________________________
|
|
I4_0. Have you
ever heard of mosquitoes with Wolbachia?
Interviewer
read the following:
Wolbachia
is a bacterium that lives inside many insects, including some
mosquito species.
There
is a type of Wolbachia that makes Aedes aegypti mosquitoes less
capable of transmitting dengue, chikungunya, and Zika viruses to
people.
Since
this type of Wolbachia has not been found in Aedes
aegypti
mosquitoes, scientists have introduced this bacterium in the
mosquitoes in a lab, so that they are less capable of
transmitting viruses.
Wolbachia
does not cause disease in humans and its use is safe for people,
animals and the environment.
Mosquitoes
with Wolbachia
can be used in two different ways.
Yes |
No | Doesn’t
know | No
response
Interviewer: Show
the visual aid for male mosquitoes with Wolbachia.
Interviewer
read the following:
This
technique can be used releasing only
male
Aedes aegypti
mosquitoes carrying Wolbachia. Female mosquitoes carrying
Wolbachia are not released. When it is used this way, it is
considered a sterile insect technique.
When
male mosquitoes carrying Wolbachia mate with wild females
without Wolbachia.
These
female mosquitoes without Wolbachia
lay their eggs, but these do not hatch.
These
mosquitoes need to be released several times per week for a
prolonged period to keep the mosquito populations low.
Mosquito
population will eventually increase again when the releases of
mosquitoes carrying Wolbachia stop.
Male
mosquitoes with Wolbachia have been used in California and the
Florida Keys and have been approved for evaluation in Miami, FL.
I4_1.
¿ Would you support the use of male
mosquitoes with Wolbachia?
Interviewer:
Read the responses.
Support
Neutral
Oppose
No response
|
|
|
|
I4_2.
What are the reasons you oppose?
Interviewer:
Do
not suggest responses. Choose all reasons mentioned below.
Use “other” for reasons not listed.
Environmental impact
Wild animal health
Human health
Pet health
Don’t think it is/would
be effective in this community
Not a community
priority/arboviruses are not a concern here
Concerned about
safety of use of mosquitoes with Wolbachia
Other:
_____________________________
|
|
Interviewer: Show
the visual aid for male and female mosquitoes with Wolbachia.
Interviewer
read the following:
There
is another way to use Wolbachia, that is not a sterile insect
technique, in which both female
and male
Aedes
aegypti
mosquitoes carrying Wolbachia
are released.
When
the female mosquito carrying Wolbachia
mates with a male mosquito with
or without
Wolbachia,
the bacterium is passed through the female to its offspring from
generation to generation.
Over
time, the amount of mosquitoes carrying Wolbachia
increases and replaces the wild mosquitoes without Wolbachia.
After
releasing these mosquitoes many times over a period of months,
the population of mosquitoes carrying Wolbachia
will stay stable without the need for further releases.
Mosquitoes
carrying Wolbachia
are less capable of disease transmission.
There
will still
be mosquitoes in the community—the intention of this
method is not the reduction of the number of mosquitoes but to
reduce the risk of disease outbreaks.
This
technology has been used in Colombia, Brazil, and other
countries. Currently, there are no established regulations for
the use of both male and female mosquitoes carrying Wolbachia
in the US.
I5_1.
Would you support the use of male
and female mosquitoes with Wolbachia?
Interviewer:
Read the responses.
Support
Neutral
Oppose
No response
|
|
|
|
I5_2.
What are the reasons you oppose?
Interviewer:
Do
not suggest responses. Choose all reasons mentioned below.
Use “other” for reasons not listed.
Environmental impact
Wild animal health
Human health
Pet health
Don’t think it
is/would be effective in this community
Not a community
priority/arboviruses are not a concern here
Concerned about safety of use of mosquitoes with Wolbachia
It
doesn’t make sense because we will still have
mosquitoes
Other:
_____________________________
|
|
I6_0. Have you ever heard of
larvicides?
Interviewer: Show
the visual aid for larvicides.
Interviewer
read the following:
Larvicides
are insecticides that kill mosquito larvae. If applied
correctly, larvicides can potentially reduce the number of adult
mosquitoes.
There
are different types of larvicides and they come in different
formulations, for example: liquid, granules and briquettes.
Liquid larvicides can be applied using truck mounted equipment,
spraying them over houses, vegetation, empty lots and other
places. In this way, this method may be effective to treat most
of the places where larvae are found.
Larvicides
can also be applied manually to water where larvae are found,
for example, fountains, tree holes, gutters, etc.
When
larvicide is used according to specific label instructions, it
does not affect the environment, people, or pets.
Larvicide
application needs to be repeated according to specific label
instructions.
Although
unlikely, with repeated use, larvae could become resistant to
the effects of larvicides. Resistance means that the larvae
resists the effects of the larvicide and don’t die.
Larvicides
are used around the world.
Yes |
No | Doesn’t
know | No
I6_1.
Would you support the use of larvicides?
Interviewer:
Read the responses.
Support
Neutral
Oppose
No response
|
|
|
|
I6_2.
What are the reasons you oppose?
Interviewer:
Do
not suggest responses. Choose all reasons mentioned below.
Use “other” for reasons not listed.
Environmental impact
Wild animal health
Human health
Pet health
Don’t think it is/would
be effective in this community
Not a community
priority/arboviruses are not a concern here
Concerned about safety of use of larvicides
Other:
_____________________________
|
|
|